4/2/14

Reese Kaplan - The Fat Lady Hasn't Sung (Yet)



After just a single game the Mets are in full panic mode given the state of their bullpen which was dealt a crippling blow Tuesday when the club announced Bobby Parnell is out indefinitely with elbow woes.  The lone shining star from Opening Day’s bullpen debacle was former closer Jose Valverde who will likely be fulfilling the late season LaTroy Hawkins role – closer in place of the injured Parnell.

The highlights of the game for the Mets included nice performances by Captain David Wright, spot starters Juan Lagares and Andrew Brown, and despite giving up 4 earned runs, Dillon Gee allowed just 6 baserunners in his 6+ IP while striking out 5. 

On the flip side, there was the 0-5 debut of Curtis Granderson with 3 Ks, the 0-4 with 4 Ks by Terry Collins’ designated guy for getting on base as the leadoff hitter, Eric Young Jr., the three first basemen going zero for the day combined and the myriad of bullpen failures by John Lannan, Bobby Parnell, Jeurys Familia, Carlos Torres and Scott Rice.  Between the birth of Daniel Murphy’s child and the flu bug hitting the clubhouse, it left Collins somewhat strapped for players yet he still managed to burn through seven pitchers in ten innings, including one inexplicable stint with four consecutive batters each facing a different pitcher. 

There’s not much more to be said about the front office’s failure to address the needs at 1st base or shortstop.  After one bad game you can’t say the bullpen is a disaster, but you hope that the long term loss of Bobby Parnell finally motivates Sandy Alderson to explore the trade route to improve the club (such as a first baseman for a relief pitcher).

In the interim, the Mets continue the youth and conditioning movement that resulted in the Bartolo Colon signing by also inking 40 year old Bobby Abreu whose best days are far behind him.  10 years ago he was a Duda-like outfielder.  Yes, he can get on base via the walk and shows some occasional power but you’d have to pinch run for him and use someone else to play the field, so I can’t really see where he has any place on the big club.  Furthermore, out in Las Vegas doesn’t it make more sense to give at-bats to the likes of Eric Campbell, Cesar Puello, Matt den Dekker and even Kirk Nieuwenhuis, some of whom might have big league careers (though likely not with the Mets).  I have to think the only way any of them get to see the big leagues at CitiField is to buy a ticket. 

While the club has made no announcement of their plans to replace Parnell’s spot on the roster, past history suggests it will be Kyle Farnsworth who has enough gray hair to make him a preferred option for Terry Collins.  Nevermind that he pitched to a 5.00+ ERA in the spring and lost more than 10 mph off his fastball.  I could see Edgin getting consideration as he is on the 40-man roster, but if they do go down the add-someone-to-the-roster route for Farnsworth then you’d like to think Socolovich with his perfect 0.00 spring should at least be a consideration.  Of course, they could also push Jenrry Mejia into the pen after he won the 5th starter’s slot and promote Daisuke Matsuzaka, but that move would be pending Jon Niese’s ability to pitch. 


About the only thing I can say thus far is that it’s déjà vu reminiscent of the entire tedious Aldersins (hat tip to Herb G for his name for the GM/Field Manager) era.  Other clubs see problems and address them.  Why can’t the Mets?

9 comments:

Mack Ade said...

Simply put, the address the bullpen like many other teams... they fill it in with waiver names near the end of the FA season.

The problem is all these teams don't make the playoffs.

We tak all the time about the St. Louis model... is there something wrong with this? Wouldn't the next step be to develop three guys that can sit 95-96 to become the 6th-9th inning firemen needed to end these games.

Dillon Gee did not deserve a 5.40 ERA. He did get himself in trouble, but that's what a pen is supposed to do... shut the problem down and put the first out.

This would have/could have been a completely different outcome if the 7th inning finished like it started.

You want to address this problem in the draft? Fine, than pick Nick Burdi or Michael Cederoth with the first pick.

You want to address this in the International market? Fine, sign someone other than a middle infielder.

And, do you want to address this within your organization? Fine... than targer 2-3 of the pitchers you have that can hit these levels of velo and turn them into relievers in the system NOW

I still think 2014 is a write off, but 2015 isn't... but you need a bullpen

Tom Brennan said...

Mack - let's say the Mets were to trade Murphy to the Yanks. Worth considering? Could they give us those arms. Honestly, I have not watched Yanks to see how valuable a Murphy would be for them as an upgrade. If not to Yanks, elsewhere? I agree pen needs to be fixed. if we had St L or Atl pens of the past 5 years, would we have won 40 more games over that span?

Reese Kaplan said...

The problem with what you both say is that it makes sense. When was the last time the Mets took an aggressive and intelligent approach to addressing a need? They overpaid for Chris Young, jury's out on Curtis Granderson, and bought into the recent two years of success to give Bartolo Colon $20 million when RA Dickey at a younger age was deemed too expensive to be worth a commitment. (Yes, I know he brought back some future players and the financial situation is somewhat better today than then.)

Take the accurate prediction of bringing up Kyle Farnsworth. You knew it would be the least sensible choice, hence for the Mets it was the obvious one.

Now they could potentially tread water in the 2nd division until June and then bring in the cavalry to do the St. Louis model, but by then things will be too far gone.

Trading Murphy might be their only chip that is both desirable to another team, has built-in options for replacement in Wilmer Flores and (ugh!) Eric Young, Jr., and frees up some payroll while keeping the 9-10 starters for 2015 intact. However, if all you bring back is a middle reliever it's not likely good value.

I'm not one to overreact to a single game and think that the pen (once they lose Germen) could be serviceable. If you're trading Murphy I'm hoping it's for a SS or a long term solution at 1B.

bgreg98180 said...

poor David Wright. He believed and trusted in the plan that Alderson presented him with. Wright deserves to play for an organization that doesn't always hope for miracles.

Mack Ade said...

Thomas -

I don't know what the Yankees have in potential relief arms.

What I know is the Mets have an excess of:

1B (Lucas Duda and Ike Davis)

2B (Daniel Murphy and Wilmer Flores)

C ( Travis d'Arnaud and Kevin Plawecki)

SP Jacob deGrom

There are four chips here that can be traded to rebuild your rotation... tomorrow.

Craig Brown said...

The means to improve this bullpen is in Vegas right now....

Degrom replaces Farnsworth
Walters replaces Germen
Leathersich replaces Lannan
Montero replaces Valverde
Black replaces Torres

Sure they'll struggle for awhile, but so what?

I'd rather watch these kids go through some growing pains, and gain some experience...than watch Farnsworth throw 88 mph heaters

Tom Brennan said...

Sean Marcum was unavailable , so Farnsworth volunteered.

Even with the pen, if you wanted some relatively cheap insurance months ago, who could that have been that s/h/b signed? Why not Latroy Hawkins? He would've been useful insurance...him instead of Germen right now? But cheap is what cheap does. I fully advocate the kids, Craig, but if they are not sharp, the first week is premature...but soon, absolutely.

Mack Ade said...

Craig -

I'm in total agreement.

Especially Montero. I don't want to lose him to my future rotation, but some great arm has to be sacrificed here to build a pen around.

I would start with Montero and deGrom in my pen.... I would keep Familia...

I know I would release Farnsworth... I would don't think Germen has the talent to make it at this level.

I need to step back and think about Lannan before I make a decision here...

Mack Ade said...

No, for now...

I keep Lannan and elevate Vic Black

My pen is now Montero, deGrom, Famiia, Black, Valverde, and Lannan