7/19/14

Morning Report – July 19th – John Mora, Dilson Herrera, Bartolo Colon, Matt Kemp


                                                                                                                                            
Coming Later Today – 
  
            10 00 am – Reese Kaplan – The Orwellian Process of Prospect Advancement

            12 00 pm - Stephen Guilbert - Shortstoptions: Get Over Starlin Castro

             2 00 pm - TRADE VALUE - SP - Matt Harvey

             5 00 pm - 2015 Draft Profile  -  RHP  -  Carson Fulmer  -  Vanderbilt - UPDATED 7-10-14





Christopher Soto

Over the last 7 starts, Noah Syndergaard is 2-3 with an extremely ugly 8.71 ERA.

However, amazingly enough he is still striking out over 20% of batters faced while walking under 5%.

This amasses to a ridiculously high .422 Batting Average on Balls In Play (BABIP).

Normalized....this comes out to a 4.08 ERA which is in line to what both Zack Wheeler and Matt Harvey were producing before their respective call ups to the majors.

(In other words.....get him the hell out of Vegas. He's pitching fine just getting extremely unlucky.) 




I’ve mentioned many times that we just can’t judge any of these baseball players at the rookie levels they play in, especially both the GCL and DSL level. The DSL is basically Latin high school ball and the GCL teams are where most teams place their high school draft picks to get used to ‘the grind’.

That being said, we need to single out OF-1B John Mora, who is simply tearing it up for the GCL team. He went 5-5 on Thursday, raising his seasonal BA to .397 and making him the BA leader in the league.

 He’s only 5-10 and has no home runs… not for the season, but his entire three year professional career that started with the DSL Mets in 2012 (.268). His .310-BA last year got him a trip stateside and I’ll turn the spyglass over to Thomas Brennan to keep an eye on this guy.

Like I said… far too early but a lot more exciting than him hitting, let’s say 100 points lower.



Let’s remember one more thing when we are trying to figure out who the Mets future shortstop is going to be:

-         AA-Binghamton 20-yr old Dilson Herrera (.326) has played about one third of his games this year at shortstop

-         Herrera was originally signed out of Columbia as a shortstop

-         Herrera considers himself a shortstop: "If you play short, you can play anywhere on the infield. I like shortstop more, because it's harder to play. I move my feet more and take charge of more stuff. It's more responsibility to play short."

Herrera is a much better hitting version of Ruben Tejada, with pop. He’s also 20-years old. Lastly, the perfect scenario for me here would be to sign Daniel Murphy to a deal through 2019, let Tejada hold down the SS fort until Herrera is ready (probably mid-season 2015) and sell off Wilmer Flores.
I’m a big Flores fan, but I simply am in love with the possibility of having both Herrera and Murphy in the same infield. 


There does seem to be a movement for all the Mets affiliates to operate with a six-man rotation at this point in the season. This might be a combination of limiting their innings to the fact that the organization is loaded with ‘B’ to ‘C’ starters.

For now, it lines up:

            Las Vegas (5):  Noah Syndergaard, Corey Mazzoni, Darin Gorski, Logan Verrett, Giancarlo Alvarado (anticipate Rafael Montero to also return next week)

            Binghamton (6): Steven Matz, Gabriel Ynoa, Rainy Lara, Greg Peavey, Tyler Pill, Matt Bowman      
                                                                                                                        
            St. Lucie (6): Michael Fuller, Matthew Koch, Kevin McGowan, Domingo Tapia, Luis Cessa, John Lannan

            Savannah (6): Robert Gsellman, John Gant, Logan Taylor, Ricky Knapp, Alex Panteliodis, Chris Flexin (I anticipate Panteliodis moving to the bullpen when Robert Whelan returns from rehabbing with the GCL team)                           
                                              
            Brooklyn (6): Marcos Molina, Casey Meisner, Cory Oswalt, Carlos Valdez, Alberto Baldonado, Octavio Acosta                         
                                                               
            Kingsport (6): Blake Taylor, Gaby Almonte, Yoryi Nuez, Andrew Church, Christian Montgomery, Craig Missigman






            - Starting Pitcher Bartolo Colon (New York Mets) – I have been tooting Bartolo Colon’s horn for seemingly months, stating that he would be a great trade acquisition for any team looking for a starting arm heading into the playoffs, despite being owed $11 Million next year. Bartolo is a slightly better pitcher than his basic numbers have indicated this season, posting a SIERA, or Skill-Interactive ERA of 3.81 this year, although Colon’s ERA sits at a mediocre at best 3.99. During his last two seasons, both with the Oakland Athletics, Colon posted an ERA of 3.43 in 2012 and 2.65 in 2013, respectively. In 2012 his SIERA was 4.26. In 2013 his SIERA was 4.10. Colon is also striking out one full batter more per nine innings in 2014 than he did in both 2012 and 2013, currently with a K/9 ratio of 6.58. Colon’s walks per nine innings are also down this year, sitting at 1.26 batters per nine innings this year, down from 2012’s 1.36 and 2013’s 1.37. What has exactly changed since than that leads to such an inflated ERA? In 2012, Colon left 76.3% of runners on base. In 2013, Colon left exactly 80% of runners stranded on base, which is absurdly high and helped contribute to his ERA of 2.65 that season. According to averages, both seasons were relatively lucky, especially the 2013 season, as 72% of batters should be left on base. Colon is only stranding 70.6% of runners on base this season with the New York Mets, a massive drop from his lucky season last year and down from both his career average of 73.1% and the general average of 72%. We should expect more runners to be stranded on base for Colon in the second half of the season. His home run to fly ball ratio is also up this season, going from 6.0% in 2013 to 9.1% this season, despite playing in Citi Field, a park with similar park factors in terms of home runs as the Oakland Coliseum. This 9.1% does however match his 2012 in Oakland, leading to two possible conclusions; Colon’s 2013 was exceedingly lucky or this year’s ratio is out of line. Unfortunately, it appears the latter is true, with his career home run to fly ball ratio sitting at 10.2%. While it does not help my case on Colon, it is something to keep an eye on for the remainder of the season to see if and how much it deviates from the current ratio.

            Mack – I love when I see other writers talk about Colon this way. He’s the one guy the Mets can sell off this month without sending signs out to the rest of the team that you’re throwing in the towels you are supposed to be waving.
I think Colon could get a pretty decent Top 100 prospect return. I’m even willing to wait a couple of years and get a future outfielder out of this transaction. Can you picture Colon in pinstripes? How about Aaron Judge?



I can’t help keep going back to this…

            As Ken Rosenthal puts it: The outfielder’s agent, former major-league pitcher Dave Stewart, told FOX Sports on Wednesday that Matt Kemp again wants to be an everyday center fielder, something that isn’t in his immediate future with the Dodgers.

Come on guys… this is Matt Friggin Kemp. He’s a real time all-star roaming out there when he’s not injured. He’s a defensive liability and probably would be the Dodgers 4th, maybe 5th choice to currently play centerfield.

From Fangraphs:

Of course, last October, Kemp had ankle surgery. It wasn’t a minor procedure, and Kemp might still be trying to get back to 100%. So we can look over a longer scale, to see how Kemp ranked before going under the knife. Over the 2004 – 2013 decade, among center fielders, Kemp ranked sixth-worst in UZR/150, and ninth-worst in DRS/150. Over just the four years between 2010 – 2013, he ranked third-worst in UZR/150, and fourth-worst in DRS/150. This is one of those situations where both the advanced metrics agree, and they agree on the idea that pre-operation Kemp was a comparable defensive center fielder to Shin-Soo Choo, who is not a center fielder.

Oh yeah… did I tell you he’s owed a little over $100mil through 2019?

The upside…

           He’s really good at hitting the snot out of the ball.

           He is hitting like shit this year:  .269/.332/.430/.762, 305-AB, 8-HR, 35-RBI

           Come on… part of you have to love the possibility of a 2015 outfield of Kemp, Granderson, and Lagares.

           Then you add Conforto and Nimmo to the mix in 2016.

           Remember… it’s not our money…

           Who would the Dodgers want in return? You’d be surprised how little they would demand if you paid the freight. Probably one AAA/AA SP and two A+/A type long range prospects

           (I can’t wait to read the responses to this one…)


           




27 comments:

Anonymous said...

I am not sure that it is wise to allocate this sort of money to any one player at all and definitely not one who recently suffered such an impactful injury and has yet to demonstrate that he can recover his pre-injury form. Those sort of contracts are an all eggs in one basket sort of approach and can hobble a team's ability to add future pieces as necessary. There may only be single digit numbers of players worth that sort of money. Tulo would be worth it for next year, but the following years could be a major risk. The Yankee teams that dominated 96-02 didn't have a monster bat. I think the Mets can field a well balanced offense and win with dominating pitching. Do I want the Tulo/Kemp sort if past production? Heck yes, but not sure it is essential to winning and I fear they become the sort of albatrosses that shackled this team for the past five years by having $20M on the DL for the year. They need a really good bat for LF and an offensive upgrade at SS, but not necessarily a HOF bound bat, especially considering the risk of such an acquisition.

Anonymous said...

While Kemp would be a potentially big acquisition my personal preference would be to trade for CarGo who word the last couple of days coming out of Colorado is that he might be available. The problem with Kemp is that he has lost his explosive first step which makes him a little one dimensional both offensively and defensively. Is that just a this year thing or permanent I don't think anyone can answer. Remember when he came up? He had stone hands in the outfield. While he made himself into a good centerfielder he has never mastered catching the ball coming off the bat with different slices and pulls in right and leftfield hence his desire to go back to center. If he truly wants to stay in center than no room for him on Mets and if he goes to left he is well below average outfielder. Pass. I actually would prefer to give the combination of Nieuwenhuis and Campbell to play leftfield for the rest of this year and then see what is available in free agency for shortstop and left or rightfield and react accordingly. With the maturation of d'Arnaud, Lagares, Duda, Nieuwenhuis, and even the OBP maching Tejada the Mets can afford to wait until the offseason to address needs of the offense. I would hate to trade for Kemp and then have to trade Murphy because there is no room in the budget.

Anonymous said...

If Rockies owner changes his mind on trading Cuddyer he would be perfect fit if he comes back healthy from shoulder injury. Friend of Wright and he is a professional hitter and has positional versatility. Would cost less to re-sign and be good in the club house.

Tom Brennan said...

Guys like Dilson make it scary to start reloading with guys with huge contracts and injury histories. If done, have a real exit strategy in place in the OF up front. So if Nimmo and Conforto are both really ready to rock in 2016, Kemp or Grandy would have to go and Mets might have to eat salary to do it. Otherwise, guys will be sitting too much.

Great win last night - the kind they routinely lost early in the year. As I'll write tomorrow AM, I am getting very optimistic.

I'd briefly demote Syndergaard, let him carve up low altitude AA hitters like a Thanksgiving turkey for 4 or 5 starts, and call him up.

Ernest Dove said...

I just don't see the Mets adding anything but 1-2 year contract veterans to man outfield right now.........lagares is now legit in my eyes.....so unless they secretly plan on trading Grandy in a year or two, I assume plan is to have Nimmo and conforto (and their years of team control) compete for spots out there, and simply keep rolling dice on a player like byrd, ey and cy typr guys for 2015-2016.

Mack Ade said...

I actually agree that bringing in someone like Kemp could have quite the downside. I throw this stuff out in the morning report to create some content and generate some opinions.

The sad part is I can't even count on this team to take care of it's own anymore. If they did, we'd have a Daniel Murphy and Dillion Gee under contract until 2019

Yes, it was a nice win

Willis said...

Craig Brown raised what I think would be a great addition for the Mets: Elvis Andrus. IF available he would cost plenty both in terms of money and prospects, but I think his contract should maintain it's value (he's young, proven, and plays a premium position of dire need). Texas is having a down year and has Profar in the wings and so may like the idea of converting Andrus into several less costly pieces. However, because of his contract he shouldn't cost a ton (ie Syndergaard or Wheeler) in trade.

Reese Kaplan said...

With all the buzz around the Mariners regarding Brad Miller and Nick Franklin, there's another SS at AAA having a whale of a season who has gone unnoticed -- Chris Taylor. To date in 319 ABs (about half a season) he is hitting .319 with 5 HRs, 37 RBIs and 13 SBs. Granted, they are PCL numbers, but he's well over .300 for his career in the minors. I'd take a flyer on someone like that in a trade for Colon.

Stephen Guilbert said...

Christopher Soto FOR THE WIN, yet again. Awesome info on Thor and I completely agree.

I would trade Bartolo if you can get a nice piece in return and promote Syndergaard. Start the future, optimize both present and beyond.

Mack Ade said...

I'm sticking to my guns...

I'm waiting to see what Alderson comes up with by the end of the month. Every win makes it impossible to be a seller, except for Colon (we could have used a little better job that last night).

That being said,Washington, Miami, and Cincy lost last night. Not as many as hoped for but three is bettwe than two.

Tonight... root for a Pirates, Braves, and Cards loss.

Oh yeah... and win.

W.T.S.

Michael S. said...

1. Sell Colon
2. Acquire Zobrist
3. Acquire Tulowitzki in the offseason


1. LF Zobrist
2. 2B Murphy/RF Granderson
3. 3B Wright
4. SS Tulowitzki
5. 1B Duda
6. Ca d'Arnaud
7. RF Granderson/2B Murphy
8. CF Lagares

SP1 Harvey
SP2 Niese
SP3 Wheeler
SP4 Syndergaard
SP5 DiceK/Matz

Eventually Conforto or Nimmo replace Zobrist with the other replacing Granderson when ready.

Stephen Guilbert said...

If you acquire Tulowitzki in the off-season, you don't have Wheeler or Thor...maybe even neither. That's what it would take.

Steve from Norfolk said...

The way Nieuwenhuis is hitting, why do we need to trade for a LF? Play him in left - we'll have three CF in the outfield!

Reese Kaplan said...

Regarding Captain Kirk, stroll over to baseball-reference.com and look at his 162 game projections. It's inferior to the pariah Chris Young. They need to upgrade the LF position though a SS who can leadoff would be my higher priority. You can slot Eric Campbell in LF to get some steadier offense but you are suffering with a guy who is in the 25th to 30th position in nearly every offensive category among ML shortstops. That's where a change needs ot happen.

Mack Ade said...

I guess we all became Yankee fans early this week :)

That Adam Smith said...

I wish we could get past this fantasy of Tulo. He'd be an expensive, risky proposition for this club, and could hamstring us for a long time. Looking over all of the debate these past couple of weeks about which young, high-end pitcher - or young established pitcher - we should be dealing makes me think that right now, we shouldn't be thinking about dealing any of them. What do you call a team with five terrific starters, and ten high-end pitching prospects? A dynasty. Kidding - sort of - but the truth is that you need so many pitchers - even if everyone pans out and stays healthy, but especially because everyone won't - that you never truly have a surplus, especially when they're cheap.

The only position that the Mets have true, expendable depth at is 2B, where we have a valuable guy at the ML level, and at least two (really more like 3+) major prospects waiting behind him. That's where you deal from. Yes, Murphy has been very good for us, but between Herrera and Flores (and Reynolds?) we can absorb his loss if it brings us back two top-100 prospects and a couple of young high-upside lottery tickets.

Dealing the potential aces - Thor, Wheeler, deGrom, or either of Gee or Neise (their consistency is a luxury that we probably don't fully appreciate) right now seems like a bad move to me at this point.

Stephen Guilbert said...

I 100% agree with everything Adam Smith writes above.

Anonymous said...

Tejada to Reese Kaplan equals Benghazi to Republicans. Dude, get over the whole Tejada thing, he is neither that big of the problem or his replacement won't be that big of the solution. Is he a HOF. No but good grief, can you look at the forest instead of obsessing over the smallest and most insignificant tree? What did this guy do to you, steal your girlfriend? We have dominant staff and BP emerging and offensive players like TDA, Duda, Lagares and Campbell stepping forward and all you want to talk about is Tejada? Talk about ridiculous

Mack Ade said...

Anonymous -

when and where did I pimp Tejada?

Steve from Norfolk said...

Reese,

Something that Kirk's projections can't show are the progress he has made this year. His eye for balls and strikes has improved.He is also hitting for a better slash line than he ever has at this level. Where before his OPS+ has always been below 100, this year its 159. Sometimes later in a minor leaguer's progression, before they end up as a career minor leaguer, a player will have a breakthrough, a "moment of clarity" if you will. Campbell has had one, and I think Kirk Nieuwenhuis has also. Playing Campbell in LF is putting him at a position where he will give an average or below-average performance, reducing the value of what he brings offensively. Kirk can succeed there, even be outstanding.

Michael S. said...

You can't assume that. It'll take pitching but there are other arms to deal.

Michael S. said...

I like Kirk and had high hopes for him when he first came up but I don't think he's more than a 4th OF.

Steve from Norfolk said...

Michael,

He's good enough to get us through until Nimmo or Conforto gets here, and a lot better than the Young brothers (sic).

Michael S. said...

I was a huge supporter of the Captain as he came through the minors. It seemed he would hit a level, struggle, and then master it and go on a monster tear. I assumed that he would follow the same pattern in the majors, but take longer as it's the highest level in the sport and many minor league stat stars have hit a wall at the MLB level.

In fairness, he maybe was not given the necessary time to make the adjustments needed at this level. He's a tremendous athlete and a hard worker. I'm rooting for him and I'd certainly take him over the Youngs. At this point though, I want to see what he can do over at least 150-200 ABs.

Duda took a while to settle in but we're seeing him become the offensive producer he was in the minors at the MLB level. If Kirk is hitting his stride now, I hope it continues. It would be great to have another homegrown position player as part of this team.

Michael S. said...

This team needs another middle of the order hitter, preferably someone who is capable of knocking in 100 or so runs. It'll change the dynamic of the entire lineup.

Is Tulo risky? Sure, but our options of finding another power bat are limited.

You're not going to acquire a power bat from a team for a couple of middle infielders. We have the depth to trade pitching AND survive just fine. If we want a MLB winning lineup an arm or two are going to have to be sacrificed.

Reese Kaplan said...

The team is set at 1st (nice to say that), 2nd (with several backups), 3rd, C, CF and RF. You have two options -- fixing LF or fixing SS. I think finding a guy who provides Eric Young type speed with high OBP and plays SS would help immensely. I'm not a Kirk believer, but a platoon of he and Campbell delivers more offense than the team is getting from SS. Consequently my priority is to address SS. There's nothing emotional about it -- it's just numbers and facts.

Tom Brennan said...

Flores has a 20 game hitting streak. Sure, he'd remind no one of Ozzie Smith (or even Adam Smith!) at SS defensively, but his bat in the Mets' line up could help prevent wash outs like last night. Can't win 'em all, but hitting is contagious. Sometimes, one more bat lights a fire and you explode and win a game you had no business winning. And I love stats, but I still think Ruben's OBP stat is very misleading due to semi-intentional walks. And his offensive contribution is therefore still minimal.

Flores would be Kevin Mitchell. And we could do a lot worse. Play him or trade him.